Ds4 mushy dpad reddit. Everything else about the controller is incredible.

Ds4 mushy dpad reddit I have the DS4 but personally outside of the duelsense it's the least reliable dpad I've used. I switch between Series X controller and DS4, and I find that QCF motions are easier on the Series X dpad, whereas KBD is easier on DS4. The membrane underneath is still the same. Lmao holy shit the down on my dpad hasnt been working for a week or so now and I just tried this and it worked. Hello everyone! I'm basically new to fighting games and just picked up GGS as my first fighting game. g. Xbox = clicky and tactile PS5 = mushy I prefer Xbox, but after a while you get used to the play station controller. Dual Sense is an option but I Best Dpad I’ve ever used with precision, There's a reason the DS4/DS5 and Saturn/Genesis fightpads are considered some of the of the best of all time, and it's not just because they "feel" good, The Ultimate's D-pad is pretty mushy, which I'm not a big fan of. If there is one thing that consistantly bothers people, it's always the dpad. My buddy thinks I’m crazy but I’m curious to hear some other opinions. Just buy like a nice amount of them, I got 2 replacements last year but they felt very mushy and less responsive than the original rubbers. The DPad on the tablet AND the pro controllers are ridiculous. It looks like it should be individual buttons but it’s actually a single piece just placed under the shell of the controller. has become seriously shit hardware to make a long story short. I don't know how you're wearing out your DS4 so fast, but I would look into learning how to do your own controller repair. I love the ds4 dpad, the ds3 dpad is just a little too small and firm for me Not of fan of the dpad they use. However, the D-pad feels Absolutely. then inside it cut out a + of a pringles plastic lid and place between the plastic dpad and the rubber contacts. Some of the best triggers I've ever felt but that dpad literally feels like it came straight from an old gamepad and that's not a compliment. The DS4 v2 I would say is precise, but again too slow for me, and I don't like the new grip at all. Give me literally Nintendo or Xbox controller other than the 360 pad and I can play fighting games 100x better Seems like a solid upgrade for the DS4. Feels really mushy and loose. I've had my controller for about a year, but the dpad has recently reached some unbearably annoying mushiness, specifically with the down and right (or both at the same time), making it I swapped the rubber pads very recently (newest DS4, bought in september 2019). Im currently using the xbox controller, since the DS4 dpad is trash imo. Get whatever fits your DS4 version. The build of the dpad is obviously different and the Xbox one dpad is clicky/not mushy DPAD, here is the debate, at first glance, Dualsense dpad feels more mushy as many users pointed out but its kind of weird. Just get your muscle memory better and you’ll start nailing it. If they could go for a more "smartphone" style touchpad, The Reddit home for PlayStation 5 - your hub for PS5 & VR2 news and discussion. Second being the PSP DPad. I use the Series X simply for the 8 way dpad, they're both about the same imo and is mainly preference but I gotta say the DS4 was the best feeling out of all controllers pads. I'm also liking the dpad on Hori Pokken Tournament controller, although the full grip the controller has isn't completely up to my liking. I find the clicks and cross shape make for a way more accurate dpad than the mushy disc feel of the ds4 dpad. Are there any known mods? For X360 I remember using a razor and sandpaper to file down the "well" area around the dpad. The dpad was average average like a Xbox Series X dpad. Motion inputs in general felt awful and With the ds4, even after replacing the rubber pads inside of it. Original XBox 1 is still my all-time favorite DPad. lol. My DS dpad was unacceptably mushy out of the box. Hitbox mayne. Honestly I'd rather hearing the clicking in the microphone. Clicky D-pads are pretty bad for fighting games, a mushy D-pad is better for most things, fighting games included. Haptics are normal and so is the dpad. I really hope it's basically the same. For example SCPH-1000R and DS4 v2 have the same hardness and are just as precise, but not only the shape of the dpad is better for me on SCPH-1000R, but also the grip will cause me always The d pad buttons are just that, buttons. Maybe you have a first gen xbone controller? The newer bluetooth one I have has a very clicky dpad that I wouldn't really describe as mushy. DS4 does the job, but it's not best in class by any means. As far as I can tell, DS4 has a stiffer silicone pad. its a great pad though! cant really go back to ds4 now after using it for a while. It’s The rubber that is seated on top of the button gets deformed really easily, and my mushy button was from it being lifted out of its spot somehow. I like how the newer xbox pads have a tactile click when you’ve pressed a direction it feels like hitting the gate on a stick and makes it easy for me to get inputs personally Sorry I live in the US, at first I didn’t like dpad popping out. They replied with a shipping label and rma instructions. I used a DS4 for about 2+ years but I only played about 2k hours on it. When it becomes a mushy mess like the DS4 situation, it it feels way less tactile and as if I’m using a faulty touchpad rather than a dpad. I went through 2 replacements until I finally decided to refund mine. Not an improvement, but not a step back either. I've been using the x360 controller for a I don't like mushy dpads and buttons but I don't feel like the dualsense ones are mushy, just soft. The Xbox 360 controller was silent, the first Xbox One (the one from 2013) was loud (D-pad and LB/RB), next revisions were silent (2015+) and now the Series X/S D-pad is loud again. Both the buttons and membrane wear over time, but it's mostly the membrane that gives you the tactile feedback/mushy feel. The dpad isn’t amazing or terrible, for me my ps5 controller started getting some bad drift so I sold it and got an Xbox controller (I’m on pc) and I think it’s dpad is WAY better than PlayStation ones, imo the ps5 controller is overall better but the dpad is very mid The dpad is far superior in terms of precision and you won't find a pro player who uses the analog stick. I don't know if it is years and years of use or if it is just built how it is but I much prefer the soft mushy dpad on the DS3. The rubber on my dpad is getting worn out and I'm starting to get a lot of diagonal misinputs. xbone pads are great and have that clicky feeling, somewhat like older style mobile phones with buttons. The activation is obviously a mouse-like micro-switch, but there's clearly ALSO a rubber membrane mush. i certainly get cleaner inputs with it than with the ds4. Dpad of dualsense is too mushy. d-pad isn't clicky at all maybe even a bit closer to mushy and the buttons are a little clicky but not on a level that would distract others when you're very similar to DS4. I never noticed much difference until I fired up one of the Persona dancing games. Halfway tempted to just sell my ps5 on ebay with /r/MortalKombat is the OFFICIAL subreddit of Mortal Kombat 1, released in September 2023, and a grass roots kommunity-run subreddit for the Mortal Kombat franchise. It is so bad that I can no longer properly wave dash in Tekken. The D-pad was getting dirty from being used all the time while I was playing Tekken with the Dualsense Controller, so I disassembled the controller into its components, and when I started to clean the controller, I saw that the Dualsense D-PAD size is very similar to my DS4 controller. That being said, it seems to be more reliable at getting a clean diagonal input, than the DS4's pad. The thing extrudes quite far which felt unpleasent at first, but once I got used to it the concave design ultimately made sliding across it a smooth experience. Just thought I'd post up in case anyone else comes across this in the future. Let me explain, the dpad isnt completely flat, its a bit curved/concave, not much but you can feel it, it feels soft and hard to use at same time. It's just the pre mushy click is annoying. I would very very very much recommend swapping these even on a brand new DS4. Damn that thing is cool. Ultimately, it will come down to your character, and your use of movement. As you can see, you'll get a ton of conflicting opinions on what's best for Tekken. Once the snackbox micro new stock is in, Ill be buying that. It's circular and doesn't feel like a traditional dpad, it's not very stiff either. The ps4 controller is lighter and much more confortable for long sessions to my hands. I tried using alcohol but no luck is there any other ideas The Reddit home for PlayStation 5 - your hub PS5 news and discussion. I'd return it and stick to my DS4 if the battery on the DS4 wasn't garbage EDIT: Yeah I got out my Xbox one controller and tested it, it functions nearly identically as the 8bitdo. along with forced advertisements on my PS5 home screen. I think the ones on the dualsense are I'm a PC gamer, and I currently use a Dualshock 4 as my main gamepad. Im not a fan of the new d-pad, like, at all. Compared to the PS4, I think the PS5 is just fine. upvotes have been using the Fight Commander for a couple of years now, and its a good fightpad for the price. the controller there is worse by a mile. Update from the worst player in Tekken Reddit History 2. but even still, get what you paid for. How would you compare it to ds4/5? For the other handhelds the steam deck isn't an option (not available in my country) and the ally size is a negative to me, so I was only ever considering the go but the dpad is the big question for me. Just a recommendation, for retro gaming try Retro-bit's Saturn controller, the dpad on those is a beast. Reply reply mechanical_animal_ • DS5 has a very tall dpad, maybe a new ds4 controller would be closer to what you want. I just finished modding this and no matter what I did, the D-pad's left and down buttons are always mushy and do not travel as far as the top and right buttons do! And there is no "click" noise as well because of this. . Are the steam decks buttons and dpad loud and clicky like the xbox series x controller or more quiet like a ps5 On mine they are pretty quiet. I just came looking to see if anyone else thought the same. Would still take some getting used to the separated if you actually want mushiness then the hori probably isnt for you. Yeah, if the dpad doesn’t feel right, that’s not how it should be. Its very soft on touch but for motions, its sightly harder to execute. Third are the Wii U controllers. This is what it looked like on all the buttons except for UP. it just feels too mushy. The dpad though, if u're not wearing earphones, the scraping hurts my ear, same as like when scratching a blackboard or chalk. The big decider is often the dpad, and it does feel strange. I definitely The dpad doesn’t regress into the controller, it just feels great all the time. It didn't matter, the dpad already felt like it was used up and mushy. I'd recommenda 3rd party controller (I still have an early DualSense and there's definitely more space for the DPAD to wiggle in the cutout. Damn sucks to hear. AND Steam recognizes the raw DS4 (along with a few other controllers, e. I’d rather go with a DS4, Gulikit King Kong, or Xbox controller The dpad is mushy enough that I think it will fail for any tight windows in combos; especially if those 1-2 frame windows require a qcf input. i got in september and the dpad is really crisp (loosens up a bit with time ofc). Before with the mushy dpad it would bottom out and you have to press hard because your also pushing on the OXP shell. Not as clicky either I guess. All I did was slap it against my hand a few times and it works again 😆 Fuck Sony 😐🖕. Feels super mushy and I drop inputs a lot with it. Does anyone have a solution to this? It’s probably not quite as bad if you have big hands but the gigantic mushy dpad on ps5 has given me more input errors than I ever got on 360. I would rma it now that I know the difference unless you really don’t use the dpad. i've only had x360 controllers for my pc for the last couple of years and well, everyone knows that dpad sucks, specially so i've been looking for a while for a great all-around controller with the best possible dpad, specially for fighting games with Ive been playing fighting games for about 5 years and have always played on pad, starting with ds3 and then moving to ds4. Haven’t tried the Pro 2, but the Pro 1 has super loud buttons and has grips that jut out at a really weird angle (both of which seem to be present on the Pro 2 based on reviews I’ve seen). I love the DS4, but I never want to buy one again because of the battery life and micro usb ports. Any mods I I bought both, dualsense feels cheap, the face buttons mushy out the box and dpad slides all over the place, but I am a fan of the haptics and triggers, haven't tried the adaptive aspect, but they feel smooth, the ergonomics of the controller feel odd, but it is reminiscent of the boomerang ps3 concept. The DS4 doesn’t have the same dpad issues as other controllers (switch pro eg) the inputs come out correctly, we just don’t always The F310's dpad is the only reason I still ever use it. I use mainly the Dualshock4, but I don't like how when I press down too hard on one direction input and slightly move it to up and down or right to left it still activates the direction and I don't really like how mushy it feels because I use a tactile keyboard. Like something was blocking it from a full press. Xbox 360/One) as Steam controllers allowing you to do interesting stuff with Steam games that support it — just like if you had one of the Valve made ones. Reply reply Sudden-Order2271 • Love finding solutions to a problem I have on year old Reddit posts, thank you View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. r/Mortal Kombat is the biggest Mortal Kombat fan resource on the internet, covering a wide range of MK culture and a premier destination for Mortal Kombat gameplay discussion, both casual and competitive! Upon booting up GG I found the right directional pad had become incredibly mushy (all other directions seem fine though). When I played SF on keyboard things were a breeze execution wise. I managed to fix mine just now by disassembling and then sliding a small off-cut of cardboard under the plastic membrane the rubber pushes onto, with a Ps4/Ps3 dpad was peak. (It will feel mushy and stuck after a while or will flicker my inputs, when im blocking it will stop for a fraction of a second and ill get hit). I've been looking forward to this controller for a long time due to all the great things i've heard about it, specially regarding its dpad. Kinda new to SF but I'm really not a fan of Series' dpad at all. There's a mushy-ness that makes games like that harder to play. It's a minute difference but the more you use it, it becomes noticeable. I’m back to the DS4 and honestly the dpad just feels mushy; my wave dash is slow as shit, I drop electrics often and I can’t omens unless I use the analog stick lmao. Just a bit mushy. The single best DPad out there is the Battle Beaver Customs DPad Buttons replacement kit for the Dual Shock 4. At least it's not the Joy-Con. Feels like I'm dropping more inputs compared to a DS4, which sucks cause I love the dpad on the DS4. It's very tactile, it's easy on the hands, takes diagonal directions well, has a comfortable shape and the controller has a special button that makes the dpad and left stick Sony has always had a very responsive and precise Dpad for fighting games from the DS1-DS3 and even better with the DS4 but they’ve really butchered this with the DS5. That's really disappointing that it seems like D pad is a bit more mushy, but after a week it matches ds4 week used pad exactly. The dpad is much stiffer than that of the DS4, and though I've gotten used to it, be warned that it still can be a bit jarring. If you use DS4Windows, then it works with everything that an Xbox 360/One controller works with since it then behaves as an Xinput device. The Xbox One dpad has been serviceable for me, but trying to use a borrowed DS4 at a tournament was an actual nightmare just because of the mushy dpad. the series x control is an evolution of the bone, the sticks, bumbers, and dpad, the Why only these two? Dualsense is a downgrade with the DPad, I’d prefer a DS4. My best advice to those having this issue, use a older version of DS4, follow HidHide instructions and make sure its hiding the ps4 controller. It registers inputs you didn’t do. It turns your pad into a miniature Hitbox, more precise, more durable, less stress on your fingers, and the modification kit is only like $25 or so. It's far better to commit to the Dpad early and build up proper muscle memory for it and harvest the long term gains rather than to gimp yourself from from start. It really all comes down to preference. I like the newer Xbox controllers with the multidirectional dpads, but the Ps5 controller doesn’t feel right. ds4 controller / ds4 with battlebeaver mod, without the mod the control feels solid but I would get misinputs so it wasn't reliable to me w the mod it made it to accurate and I would mis diagonal because of the mod ds5 control - this controller sucks ass lol its a step down from the ds4, the dpad is really unreliable many misinputs. I have put easily 15 hours into my controller, I have tested it in CoD, Tekken 7 and Sonic Adventure DX (a game that I am EXTREMELY adept at, to the point that I have held multiple Speedrun world records in) Now here is my update/ review. How do your face buttons feel in comparison to the regular DualSense? My Edge controller’s face buttons felt real mushy like and almost as if it didn’t have much of a press to them. Or my ds4 dpad has become sensitive/mushy (tactile feel) Anyone else? My dpad has gotten loose on the right direction only, the rest of the directions feel great to be pressed and spring back quickly Not normal anymore, I bought a new Dualsense for my PC, it's d-pad doesn't wobble at all compared to my Day 1 Dualsense, the button presses are more correct, and overall akin to ds4. Feels kinda mushy Reply reply More replies [deleted] Update from the worst player in Tekken Reddit History 2. I love the controller and consider it one of the most comfortable controllers I've ever used. It does NOT feel like a mouse click, it feels like a mouse click It's mushy and doesn't register how I KNOW it would register on a Series X pad. Your issue is honestly just an execution issue, which is good cause it can be fixed with practice and grinding. I find my directional inputs are much better. I can Korean back dash on the DS3 but on DS4 I struggle so I use ss cancel instead Right D-pad on mine stoped working. Home of Street Fighter on reddit, The Reddit home for PlayStation 5 You can put in the DS4's silicone pad, to make it less mushy! When I look back to the DS4, it looks "kiddy" with it's colors and black buttons compared to the very sleek contemporary see-through look of DualSense's face/d-pad buttons. If you're used to playing Tekken on a pad already, and especially if you're not planning to play tournaments or anything and just want something familiar that doesn't take up much space, you can really just get a PS4 pad, or a Hori Fighting Commander. At first I thought it was just placebo, but I picked up a standard controller recently and couldn’t even pull off charge moves consistently on the pad. Absolutely horrendous trying to play Mishimas with this garbage ass pad. Seems that once it tears past half way it turns into mush. I certainly feel it. Half circles were a pain in the ass on the dual sense. Consider joining r/PlayStation for The DPad is just slightly too high for me. Seems that once it tears past half way it turns into My dpad has gotten loose on the right direction only, the rest of the directions feel great to be pressed and spring back quickly (tactical feel?) but the right button feels as if I'm not pressing I recently got two new Dualshock 4s, and the D-Pads on both of them are super mushy and rock back and forth under my thumb when I hold any of the up/down/left/right The D-pad is good/fine (I can't compare it to the DS4 or Xbox one/series) but I think the face buttons could stand out a little more. I think the Series X dpad is pretty good for Tekken, though, and as a controller I like it better overall than the DS4. My friend could run that controller into the dirt in about 3 months because he simply plays more. Plus, make sure the second "controller" creating the double input isnt being used by anything (mine was being selected for audio, weirdly enough), then Hidhide hiding mechanic should work. I just got the new SN30 Pro and can happily say that I’m not seeing any false diagonals. I started out with an xbone controller, so I never liked the mushy feeling of the DS4 dpad, and the FC's dpad definitely doesn't I swapped the rubber pads very recently (newest DS4, bought in september 2019). Ds4 is your only option really. The DS4 d-pad is still my favourite to play platformers like Hollow Knight and Celeste, especially since Nintendo really screwed up with their d-pad even on the pro controller this gen. Appreciate the clickyness, but I'm not a fan of how it feels. Recently ive noticed that i go through a ps4 dpad in about a year. This pad made electrics easy, too bad I had to make the dualsense dpad mushy and loose before I got to near the same consistency I got with the ds4, I played a couple fighting games on ps3 but like all Sony controllers the mushy dpad and weird triggers make playing anything on there feel terrible. If it weren't for it's placing I might've just stuck with it. If you press dpad down and move your thumb to the right part of the button it will register a right-dpad-input I like the segmented dpad and it being above the stick, but I havent used pad for fighters in a while. eXtremeRate Ergonomic Split Dpad Buttons. But interesting to hear that your X is better, which proves that it's definitely not intentional for them to feel like mushy clacky shit if it's only one of the buttons this time. Yes, there isn't enough click to differentiate between the directions on DS4. The ps5 controller makes me sore my hand hurt just from holding it for longer than 30 minutes and I never felt this with the ps4 controller, not even once after playing for The feeling of the dualsense is way better than the ds4 yet they seem to break so much more quickly than them and the buttons and dpad are a step down. Like they work but it takes killing my hands to get them to, whereas like, ig the best dpad I've used is probably the series x. The 'arrows' are tapered down in the center so its easy to roll or slide. The only thing I dont like is the Dpad and buttons feels pretty mushy/soft which sometimes makes me miss my inputs like blocking or calling assists. I replaced the DS4 with an 8bitdo Pro 2 which was serviceable after modding the dpad but the shoulder buttons gave out in less than a year. So I went with it. It doesn't feel that responsive, but it seems like The ds dpad is the best one. After replacing it with the DS4 dpad it now feels much more tactile and fast. Everything else about the controller is incredible. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. ) Whether or not it's better than PS4s DS4 is debatable, but having played Tekken on XBOX Series X. Just as you described. makes them feel less tactile but the DPad is def worse. Really glad I did. Comparing it with the xbox one, it's definitely an improvement. Solves all your problems. I prefer the DS3. People will come up Update: about the l3 and r3, it's not mushy, rather, there's a pre 'mushy click' before the actual input click. But after awhile it grew on me and I notice because it’s raised button press are more accurate. It is interesting that Microsoft actually goes back and forth with the controller click noise. The actual input is clicky, yeah. thought it was a Rise of the Ronin glitch. However, the dpad feels a bit too stiff for my liking. The Reddit home for PlayStation 5 it is less “stiff” than the DS4, so that might be why it feels less tactile to you, are almost the same to push but softer by release due the additional rubber . The dpad is definitely an upgrade for me but it feels very mushy. It's simply not well suited for the type of inputs required here. XB360 also didn't have a good dpad, I remember playing T6 and DOA 4 on there and it was horrible. I have others pads like Dualshock, Dualsense, 8BitDo M30, Fighting Commander and Madcatz fightpad, but the dpad of Series X controller is now my favorite for fighting games !. It’s not as mushy as the one on the SNES Classic controller, the Switch Pro controller or the DS4. This increased the throw range a bit, made it clicky and more responsive. I'm not sure about the durability, but my DS4 has pretty bad drift on both sticks so it's Home of Street Fighter on reddit, I used to play fighting games with ds4 and the dpad was pretty decent. Some people like firm ones or clicky. So, out of curiosity, I changed that hard acrylic kind of metarial Dualsense Dpad with my old DS4 Also in case of DS4 you do have to consider that the style of the grip is different, the angle of your hands changes and so even if the dpad is up to your liking, playing using DS4 may not be. In the beginning I was turned off by it, but it doesn't seem like I'm registering too many wrong inputs and my kbd is actually improved on this pad. I didnt like the Elite D-pad much, even though it was concave, because it was clicky. The travel distance when you press down on a direction is very small compared to a ds4 so it can feel more responsive, and they don't get that mushy feeling until it breaks - which is probably the main issue with the controller as the dpad will break in less than half the time I recently dropped my controller and a couple hours ago I realized that my “x” on my controller has gone mushy and not the normal click as it should be. Feelwise I wouldnt describe using it as clicky or soft, very 'medium' while I do, buuuut compared to the new Xbox dpad the PS5 holds no water. This has happened previously on my old DS4 but I put it down to it being an older controller a friend of mine had given me. Mushy dpads just don't work for me. I am always baffled at how nitpicky people are over the dpad whenever it comes to any video game controller or portable device these days. It feels euphoric. After all the hype I read prior to buying it the dpad on this thing sucks. This was on day 2 of responsible use and no spills. will never buy another one of their products again. I bought my replacement from xqgaming(eu). Unlike the other controllers mentioned I played a lot on the hori fighting commader but the dpad is mushy, saw on reviews of the Razer Raion the dpad is almost perfect but the fact that it does not have a center pivot and the ds4 dpad also seems kinda criticized despite of apparently beint better than the dualsense one. This is the early adopter tax. It’s decent and usable, but every-time I pick up an XOne controller my thumb just nestles into that Dpad like a baby chick resting in a nest. Surprisingly, the dual sense edge is much, much better than the standard PS5 controller. Only Posted by u/Electrical_Big_3104 - 3 votes and 2 comments Been playing fighting games for ten years, and the DS4 is my favorite d-pad so far. khoqe wkev qbduo klvad lvykhmd wetcv xoi hxmxflz edenbdv zuh